Start with the data, not the label
“No-log” is a provider's description of its practices, not a separate networking protocol. Two services can use similar connection technology while retaining different information. Read the privacy policy for activity records, connection metadata, account details and diagnostics as separate categories.
A practical comparison sheet needs four columns: the data item, whether it is collected, how long it is retained, and the stated purpose. Put unanswered questions in the sheet rather than treating silence as a promise. This makes vague marketing language easier to challenge.
Account data and browsing records are different
A service can need an account or billing record without keeping a list of the pages you visited through the VPN. Conversely, a short retention period is still retention. Look for clear statements rather than assuming that “anonymous”, “private” and “no logs” all mean the same thing.
If you are comparing providers, use the same questions for each one. Record the policy date and keep a link to the document you read. That gives you something concrete to revisit when ownership, infrastructure or terms change.
What an audit adds
An independent audit can provide evidence about a particular system and period. It is more useful when the report explains the scope, methods, exclusions and findings. A badge or headline alone does not tell you whether auditors examined production infrastructure or only reviewed written policies.
Our audit checklist shows how to read that evidence. Proton VPN's published audit page is one example of a provider making its evidence available; it is not proof that every VPN using similar language behaves the same way.
Decide what problem you are solving
A VPN changes the network path your traffic takes. It does not erase your signed-in identity or prevent every form of browser tracking. If your problem is reused passwords, start with a password manager and multi-factor authentication instead. If your goal requires a particular VPN feature, check that feature directly rather than using “no logs” as a substitute.
The useful purchase decision is therefore specific: you trust a provider enough for a defined task, understand its limits, and have checked the current evidence. That is a stronger basis than expecting one subscription to make every online action anonymous.