Ubuntu 11.10 vs Windows 8: Design, Features & Download

by Joel Fernandes 19

When Microsoft announced Windows 8 and released the developer version, it created a lot of buzz around the Internet. With all the new Metro UI and Cloud integration, Windows 8 has certainly taken a huge step in the world of computing. However, the buzz that Windows 8 created was all diverted towards Ubuntu 11.10, when the folks at Canonical released it few days back.

Microsoft’s Windows has managed to lead the competition in the Desktop OS market with 91.9 percent market share, while the Mac OS has a 6.9 percent market share. However, now the popularity of Ubuntu is rising, and Microsoft has a new level of competition in the OS market. Ubuntu is the next big challenge for Microsoft and it might prove Microsoft wrong, which once thought that Linux was over and done with.

When I had my first glimpse at the Microsoft Windows 8 developer version, I was totally impressed with its looks and features. However, I was more captivated and fascinated towards Ubuntu 11.10, and just like a small kid, I was excited about it. And certainly, Ubuntu kept up to my expectations by bringing in vast improvements and many awaited features.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8:

Let’s take a close comparison between Ubuntu vs Windows 8.

Ubuntu vs Windows

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – User Interface

I must admit, both Ubuntu and Windows 8 have an extraordinarily beautiful design with highly refined glass effect and high resolution icons. Windows 8 will be using the Metro UI, while Ubuntu sports the Unity Interface.

The Windows 8 interface supports gestures, snap, pin, cloud applications, sharing of apps and services, hidden task bar on the right of the screen and so on. The Metro UI is a huge step taken towards design and UI by Microsoft, and is certainly far more striving than any other UI we have seen before. This also fits in with tablets, as Microsoft demonstrated the OS running on tablets from Samsung and Lenovo.

Ubuntu’s UI on the other hand has an improved Unity Interface with richer set of “Scopes and Lenses”, instead of the old “Places” function. Since users were confused and didn’t know what to click on, Canonical decided to integrate Ubuntu icons with the Dash and Unity launcher, for providing more visibility.

Widows vs Ubuntu - Design
Clicking the Dash (or the Ubuntu logo on the left) will bring up a glossy set of icons, which are most commonly used – Browse the Web, View Photos, Check Email or Listen to Music. It comes with a search bar which will be frequently used by users. It’s not just easy to search, but it is blazingly fast. The left panel consists of applications which are most commonly used, and users have the option to add an application by simply dragging it in or remove it.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Social Networking

All of us have used Windows and we all know that Windows mainly lacked the social networking feature. From the Windows 8 version onwards, Microsoft has decided to integrate essential social media features in its desktop. Ubuntu on the other hand, has always included social media features in its default desktop. Gwibber has been Ubuntu’s default social media client, and with the release of Ubuntu 11.10 aka Oneiric Ocelot, Gwibber has been revamped which is faster, lighter and prettier than its previous version.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Cloud IntegrationCloud Services

Windows 8 and Ubuntu 11.10 will both be integrated with the cloud. This will enable the OS to download photos and apps from the cloud, share with friends and upload them on the go. Additionally, Ubuntu 11.10 will support the Ubuntu One, a free online backup service with 5 GB of cloud storage. You can avail more space by pay plans – $2.99/month or $29.99/year.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Editing Tools/Software Applications and App Store

Ubuntu 11.10 comes with free photo editing tool called Gimp, and Open Office for word processing. However, for Windows 8 you need to purchase a licensed version of MS Office. The free applications that Windows 8 comes with are Windows Live messenger and Internet Explorer 10.

Apart from that, Windows 8 will have a Windows Store, similar to Apple’s App Store, enabling users to download and purchase new application for their desktop. Ubuntu on the other hand has always offered an App Store-like ability to add or remove open-source applications. With Ubuntu 11.10, the Software Centre is more shopper-friendly, with reviews and ratings and is much faster than it was before. This makes app discovery a lot easier.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Boot Time

In terms of speed and booting, Ubuntu wins the race. The boot time of Ubuntu is quicker than Windows 8, and there’s no doubt about it. Ubuntu is light and designed in a way to perform faster. It is faster on both old and new hardware configurations, while Windows boots faster than Windows Vista on old hardware.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Login Screen

Ubuntu has the LightDM as the new default login screen. LightDM brings easy customization and can be tweaked with a tool called LightDM Manager. This will allow you to change the background as well as the logo of Ubuntu 11.10 login screen.

Windows vs Ubuntu - Login Screen
The Windows 8 lock screen is similar to the Windows Phone lock screen, displaying the date/time, scheduled appointments and unread message summaries. You can personalize the login screen by changing the background to something of your own. Windows 8 supports the traditional password login or the new picture password tool, where you can select a picture to use as a reference grin to create a three-point pass gesture.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Availability and Customization

Ubuntu has always been free, and continue to remain free. You can customize the OS to the maximum level possible, and the only cost involved is the download time and nothing else. Windows 8 and its earlier versions have to be purchased and cannot be customized whatsoever.

Ubuntu 11.10 is available for free download and can be procured from the Ubuntu website. You can also download the Windows Installer from here, and follow the step-by-step guide to install it.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Download and Try Both

Download Link for Ubuntu 11.10:

[Direct Download] Download Ubuntu 11.10 Desktop Edition (x86 version)
[Direct Download] Download Ubuntu 11.10 Server Edition (x86 version)
[Direct Download] Download Ubuntu 11.10 Desktop Edition (x64 version)
[Direct Download] Download Ubuntu 11.10 Server Edition (x64 version)

Alternatively, Users currently running Ubuntu 11.04 on a desktop can upgrade in place via the command update-manager -d.

Windows 8 is currently released under beta version, and the developer preview can be obtained from the Microsoft website. Here’s the direct download link for Windows 8 Developer Preview:

[Direct Download] Windows 8 Developer Preview with developer tools English, 64-bit (x64) (4.8 GB)
[Direct Download] Windows 8 Developer Preview English, 64-bit (x64) (3.6 GB)
[Direct Download] Windows 8 Developer Preview English, 32-bit (x86) (2.8 GB)

Try Ubuntu before Downloading

One great thing about Ubuntu is that you can try the OS from the cloud without having to install it. If you’re impressed with the demo, then you can continue downloading it. Click here to try Ubuntu 10.11 for free.

Unfortunately, there isn’t any option to try Windows 8 without having to download. We can probably expect such an experience in the next release of Windows.

Ubuntu vs Windows 8 – Who Wins?

It’s certainly a tough job to decide who wins the Ubuntu vs Windows 8 race. When it comes to usage, I think Windows will do a better job, however in terms of design and functioning, Ubuntu gets the reward. Overall both the OS are good in their own way. Since I favor Ubuntu, I would vote it the best. What about you? Please answer the Ubuntu vs Windows 8 poll question and let us know why your thoughts through comments.

Comments (19)

  1. I love ubuntu but the deal-breaker for me is the fact that you cannot stream netflix (netflix uses silverlight).

    1. I believe there’s a silverlight clone for linux… not entirely sure though

      either way there is currently a linux client being worked on

      1. Novell has one called Moonlight, developed in cooperation with Microsoft that allows Silverlight to run on Linux Distros.

  2. Yeah I like ubuntu too, but the deal-breaker for me is that you can’t run everthing on WINE.

    1. I understand where you’re coming from, but you have to understand that you shouldn’t expect to be able to run everything on wine. Windows and Ubuntu are completely different operating systems and to complain that you can’t run windows programs on ubuntu is more or less the same as complaining that you can’t run iOS apps on windows. The fact that wine even exists is amazing, what other operating systems do you see that have any compatibility for files from other OS’s? you don’t see windows running .deb’s or .rpm’s.

      Also, I’ve yet to find a major application that isn’t either replaceable with a fully functional alternative, already compatible with linux, or executable in wine.

  3. I like Ubuntu because is not windows and because virus/malaware/trojans and many others don’t work, unless you have wine. I’ve been testing other debian base linux and i’ll ditch ubuntu 11.10 because it’s to slow.

    Not in some many words ubuntu = windows…

    1. Ubuntu 11.10 has very many faster & lighter clones. Canonical has Xubuntu 11.10, which I use, in both 32 & 64 bit. Unlike Windows, 32 bit is not limited to only 3.5 GB of RAM. The only point AGAINST Linux is the availability of quality software, of practically every kind. But it has enough good software that it remains my mai

  4. I like Ubuntu because is not windows and because virus/malaware/trojans and many others don’t work, unless you have wine. I’ve been testing other debian base linux and i’ll ditch ubuntu 11.10 because it’s to slow.

    Not in some many words ubuntu = windows…

  5. netflix its being developed for linux

  6. NIce comparison… Thanks… But why does the title say Ubuntu 10.1? Shouldn’t it be Ubuntu 11.10?

    1. @write2nix Thanks for pointing that out!

    2. @write2nix

      because .1 means 1 tenth so if you change to .10 it is the same thing.

      1. @[email protected] Ubuntu version number based on the year and month of the release. So if you write Ubuntu 11.1, it will be Ubuntu release for January 2011, which never existed.

        10.10 = October 2010

        11.04 = April 2011

        11.10 = October 2011

        12.04 = April 2012

        And so on…

  7. This is really revealing about both– Windows just catching up to some of the old standby features, and adding new ones.
    At the same time, Ubuntu’s 12.04 LTS login screen is the user’s desktop background making for even prettier and more easily customizable experience. Not to mention that Unity’s Dash Home page includes not the quick links it had before, but your recently used apps, files, folders, and even downloads!

    1. @JamesRead I like how they just skip over all of the admin functionality and enterprise class features of windows. Ubuntu is a shell of what windows is, so it includes a chat client. Yippee… But can’t you at the click of a few buttons completely control and change the OS and user accounts remotely without enabling a bunch of code and scripting. These reviews are biased and rubbish.

      1. @Chrisb1070 Ha. I knew someone would hit on that. Ever heard of Ubuntu Tweak? And did you know that the classic control panel is being phased out along with the desktop? And may I also add all of the features that are added by Canonical for remote system management in the “System Settings” dialogue? I would hardly call that code and scripting, and it is also much more than what is included in Windows.
        Another good point is other reviews. Every review I have read about Windows 8 calls it “an awful business solution,” and every Ubuntu review calls it “A desktop for the newbie and businessman alike.” I have talked to many friends who have (like me) used Windows 8. Every one of them has a problem of some sort because of how little a mouse is supported on its own. I will admit- a touchscreen is cool, but it cannot stand alone without a mouse, nor does everyone have one, nor can the touchscreen fare very well on its own in W8. It is great for an ultrabook, but wake up people. This is being sold on desktops and laptops without touchscreens too, and on tablets that have no mouse.
        I would point out again, that Ubuntu fares well with only one or the other– while keeping all of the application interfaces that people already know. Drag to scroll is supported with a touchscreen, and using the overlay scrollbars or a scrollwheel on a mouse is smooth, and on top of it all, screen space is saved through the unification of menubar and statusbar: something only done in Mac OS otherwise.
        And Ubuntu- if anything- is not a shell of Windows, nor is Windows a shell of Ubuntu. They are completely different products, each with their own interface. One of the only limiting factors of Ubuntu is that its shell, dubbed “Unity,” is merely a shell of GNOME. I might also point out that every feature that Windows has “introduced” since 2008 or so had already existed in Ubuntu and other linux distributions for a fair amount of time already.

      2. @Chrisb1070  @JamesRead As I said below, with all of the interface AND admin features of Ubuntu, the company wanting good management is hardly left out.

  8. here is another compareation http://linuxconfig.net/media/featured/ubuntu-12-04-vs-windows-8-review.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>